KnowledgeISO 27001
Why your IT administrator cannot do the internal audit
It seems so logical. Your IT administrator knows the systems best, so let him do the internal audit. Yet that is exactly what leads to a nonconformity at the certification audit. Not because he is not capable, but because he would be assessing his own work.
Updated on By the IT auditors of AudIT-Sure
The short answer
ISO 27001 does not prohibit any role from being an auditor. The standard does require the internal audit to be objective and impartial. Anyone who has implemented a control or performs it daily cannot independently assess that same control.
So your IT administrator may well audit, just not the part he is responsible for himself. And in most organisations that is precisely the largest part of the management system.
What the standard requires
Clause 9.2 of ISO 27001 requires you to select auditors and conduct audits in such a way that the objectivity and impartiality of the audit process are ensured. The guideline for auditing, ISO 19011, elaborates on this: auditors are, where possible, independent of the activity they assess, and free from bias and conflicts of interest.
The guideline acknowledges that full independence is not always feasible in a small organisation. But you must then do everything you can to remove bias, and be able to explain how you did so.
Where it goes wrong
These are the situations that raise questions at a certification audit:
- The auditor assesses controls that he has implemented or performs himself.
- The auditor is also the person who has to resolve the findings.
- The security officer who manages the ISMS performs the entire internal audit.
- It has not been documented why the auditor is competent and independent.
- The audit programme does not cover the whole management system, because the only auditor is not allowed to assess part of it.
Three workable solutions
There are three ways to arrange this properly. Which one fits depends on your size.
A colleague from another department
Someone from finance or quality assesses the IT part, and the IT administrator assesses another part. This does require training in auditing.
A peer organisation
You audit each other's management system. Independent and instructive, but it takes time to organise and you share sensitive information.
An external auditor
An outside auditor performs the internal audit on your behalf. The standard allows this: the requirement is impartiality, not that the auditor is employed by you.
What an external internal audit delivers
Besides solving the independence issue, organisations mainly notice this:
- A fresh view from someone who works with standards frameworks every day and knows what certification bodies look for.
- Findings that have been tested for operating effectiveness, not just for the presence of a document.
- A report that can be used directly for the management review.
- No employee who loses days on a task he does once a year.
Frequently asked questions
Can our security officer do the internal audit?
Only for parts he is not responsible for himself. Anyone who manages the management system cannot independently assess its operating effectiveness.
Is outsourcing the internal audit mandatory?
No. The standard requires objectivity and impartiality. How you arrange that is up to you.
Does this also apply to NEN 7510?
Yes. NEN 7510 sets the same requirement for internal audits as ISO 27001.
AudIT-Sure already supports our ISMS. Can you then also do the internal audit?
Yes, but always by a different auditor from our team than the one who supports your ISMS. That keeps the opinion objective.
Further reading
Your internal audit arranged independently?
In a short conversation we discuss your scope, your schedule and what an internal audit involves for your organisation.