KnowledgeAssurance
ISAE 3402, SOC 2 or ISO 27001: what do you need?
A client asks for an ISAE 3402 report. A tender requires ISO 27001. And an American prospect wants to see SOC 2. What is the difference, and which one do you really need? The short answer: that depends on who is asking, and why.
Updated on By the IT auditors of AudIT-Sure
The short answer
Is your client's auditor asking for it? Then you need ISAE 3402. Do your clients want assurance on your information security, in detail? Then SOC 2 fits. Is a tender or procurement department asking for a certificate? Then that is ISO 27001.
They are not mutually exclusive. Many service providers have two, and a large part of the work overlaps.
Which report or certificate do you need?
Find the route that fits your client’s request: ISAE 3402, SOC 2 or ISO 27001.
Take the quick scanThe three in one table
| ISAE 3402 | SOC 2 | ISO 27001 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What is it? | Assurance report | Assurance report | Certificate |
| About what? | Controls that are relevant to your client's financial reporting | Security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality and privacy | Your information security management system |
| Who issues it? | An independent auditor | An independent auditor | An accredited certification body |
| Who asks for it? | Your client's auditor | Clients and their security or procurement department, often international | Tenders, procurement and supply chain partners |
| What does the reader get? | A detailed report with the controls tested and the results | A detailed report with the controls tested and the results | A certificate, without insight into the underlying findings |
Report or certificate: the essential difference
ISO 27001 results in a certificate. It says that you have a working management system, but not which controls were tested and what was found. For many buyers that is enough.
ISAE 3402 and SOC 2 result in a report. It states which controls the auditor tested, how, and with what result, including the exceptions. It is not a quality mark that you put on your website, but a document for your clients and their auditors. That openness is exactly what makes it valuable for anyone who has to rely on your services.
Type I and Type II
ISAE 3402 and SOC 2 come in two variants. A Type I report covers the design and existence of your controls at a single point in time: are they described and have they been implemented?
A Type II report goes further and also tests operating effectiveness over a period, usually at least six months. This is the report that auditors and larger clients ultimately ask for. Many organisations start with Type I and then move on to Type II.
ISAE 3402, SOC 1 and SOC 2: how does that work in the Netherlands?
The names get mixed up. ISAE 3402 is the international standard and corresponds to what is called SOC 1 in the United States. If a client asks for SOC 1, ISAE 3402 will serve.
SOC 2 is an American framework with fixed criteria. In the Netherlands, a SOC 2 examination is performed under the international standard ISAE 3000. That is why you often see the combination of ISAE 3000 and SOC 2 together.
The decision rule in three questions
Go through these questions. The first one you answer yes to determines where you start.
- Does your service affect your client's figures, such as payroll processing, invoicing or financial administration? Start with ISAE 3402.
- Do your clients mainly ask about the security and availability of your platform, or do you work with international clients? Start with SOC 2.
- Is a certificate a hard requirement in tenders or contracts? Start with ISO 27001.
Do you answer yes to more than one question? Then combining is sensible. Controls you have implemented for ISO 27001 can be used in an ISAE 3402 or SOC 2 report, and vice versa.
Frequently asked questions
Is ISAE 3402 the same as SOC 1?
In practice, yes. ISAE 3402 is the international standard, SOC 1 the American name for the same type of report.
Can I put an ISAE 3402 report on my website?
No. The report is intended for your clients and their auditors, not for general distribution. You can state that you have a report and share it on request.
How long does it take before I have a Type II report?
Allow for the preparation plus the period the report covers, usually at least six months. With a readiness assessment you know in advance what still needs to be done.
Does AudIT-Sure also issue the ISO 27001 certificate?
No. The certificate is issued by an accredited certification body. We make sure you are well prepared, so that the certification audit runs without surprises.
Further reading
ISAE 3402
Independent assurance on your internal control.
SOC 2
Show that your information security and privacy are well organised.
ISO 27001 internal audit
Independently assessed, before the certification body visits.
Readiness Assessment
The best preparation for an audit, certification or assurance engagement.
Not sure which one suits you?
In a short conversation we discuss what your clients ask for and which report fits that.